Pizza is one of those things that everyone seems to love. There are so many different variations of pizzas pies, and each person has their own favorite place to get them. If you’re looking for the best pizza in New Paltz, look no further! We’ve compiled a list of the best pizza places in town, so you can find your new favorite spot. Whether you’re looking for a classic cheese pizza or something more adventurous, we’ve got you covered. So what are you waiting for? Grab a slice (or two) and enjoy!

Rino's pizza square pizza new paltz, new york

The Top 8 Pizza Shops in New Paltz, New York

Village Pizza

Village Pizza is a retro fast-food–style joint that serves up pizza, pasta, and subs. We have outdoor tables for dining in, as well as a drive-thru for grabbing a quick meal on the go. Our pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and our subs are piled high with meats and cheeses. Stop by today for a delicious meal!

Village pizza pacific veggie pizza new paltz, new york

La Bella Pizza Bistro

Craving something truly unique? La Bella Pizza Bistro is the perfect spot for specialty pies that will tantalize your taste buds. From classic Italian staples to vegan-friendly options, this pizzeria has something for everyone. Plus, with local artwork on display, it’s a great place to take a break from every day and enjoy some culture too.

Moving company

Pasquale's Pizza & Restaurant

Looking for a laid-back Italian eatery that offers up plenty of pizzas, subs, and salads? Look no further than Pasquale’s Pizza & Restaurant. Our all-you-can-eat pasta special is the perfect way to fill up on carbs, and our pizza selection is sure to please everyone in your group. Come see us today!

Pasquale's pizza & restaurant pepperoni jalapeno new paltz, new york

Rocco's Pizzeria

Rocco’s Pizzeria is a great place to go to relax and enjoy some delicious pizza. They offer a variety of pies and slices, as well as soups and salads that you can customize to your liking. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it the perfect place to unwind after a long day.

Rocco's pizzeria pizza paradiso new paltz, new york

Gourmet Pizza

Introducing Gourmet Pizza, the best place to get your fix of delicious, handcrafted pies. Our family-run pizzeria is open late at night, serving up specialty pies, heros, and wings in simple digs. Whether you’re looking for a classic cheese pizza or something more adventurous like our Thai chicken pie, we’ve got something to satisfy everyone’s taste buds. Come by and see us today!

Gourmet pizza half buffalo chicken half bbq chicken new paltz, new york


Introducing the Apizza, a delicious and innovative take on the classic pizza. Our talented chefs have created a variety of mouth-watering specials that will tantalize your taste buds. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pizza or something more adventurous, we’ve got you covered. So come on over to Apizza and enjoy some of the best pizza in town!

Apizza brooklyn pizza new paltz, new york

Rino's Pizza

Rino’s Pizza is a New York-style pizza joint known for its delicious pies and signature red sauce. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic grandma pizza or something a little more adventurous, Rino’s has got you covered. Plus, what’s better than sitting down to a slice (or two) of piping hot pizza? Nothing, that’s what. So come on over to Rino’s Pizza and taste for yourself what makes this place so special. You won’t regret it!

Rino's pizza margherita flatbread pizza new paltz, new york

Lunch Nightly

Introducing Lunch Nightly, a new eatery in the heart of downtown. We serve sandwiches, salads, and locally sourced meats alongside cocktails, wine, and beer. Our pizza is specially made with fresh ingredients that will tantalize your taste buds. Whether you’re looking for a casual place to catch up with friends or an evening out on the town, we’ve got you covered. Come see us today!

Lunch nightly location new paltz, new york

Credit: https://www.yelp.com/

Need help moving your stuff? Contact us!

Your Hometown Mover

Your Hometown Mover is a family-owned and operated business located in Boca Raton, Florida. We offer high-quality, full-service moving, and storage at half the cost of major van lines. Our motto is to provide “great customer service at an affordable price” so we are committed to proving that we are the best local mover in the Hudson Valley by offering our PRICE MATCH GUARANTEE.

Call Your Hometown Mover Now!

Your Hometown Mover 

980 N Federal Hwy, Suite 110 Boca Raton, FL 33432



Weather in New Paltz, New York

New Paltz
Wednesday, 16
See 7-Day Forecast

Weather in New Paltz, New York

Scroll to Top

Limited Time Offer

Now Offering

Move Now, Pay Later

with 0% APR Financing

No Hourly Minimums

on ALL Local Moves!

MoveMatch Guarantee

So you get the BEST price!

Get A Free Moving Quote Today!